Hacking Chinese

A better way of learning Mandarin

Panning: How to keep similar Chinese characters and words separate

similarcomponentsDo you know what the real challenge of learning Chinese characters is? Some people who are good at learning things but haven’t learnt Chinese ask what the problem is; memorising a few thousand facts isn’t that difficult.

That’s true, but it also misses the point. The problem with learning thousands of Chinese characters is to keep them separate from each other and remembering how they fit together into words and sentences. That’s the real challenge.

It goes without saying that this becomes harder the more characters you learn. For beginners, the main problem is to just learn the characters, but the more advanced you become, the bigger the problem of keeping things separate becomes. The things I talk about in this article will probably be more useful for intermediate and advanced learners.

Zooming in, zooming out and panning

In this series of articles, I’ve given you the information and resources you need to integrate the different levels of learning Chinese with each other, showing both how you break things down and how you put them in context.

  • Zooming in Moving from a higher to a lower level: sentences to words to characters to components. Breaking things down in order to understand them.
  • Zooming out Moving from a lower to a higher level: components to  characters to words to sentences. Putting things in context in order to understand them.
  • Panning (this article) – Exploring the nearby areas of the web without either zooming in or out. Understand how similar things are different and how different things are similar.

In this final article, I will look at panning, which is horizontal references on the same level. In other words, it’s about how to keep components, characters and words separate from each other.

Understanding how similar things are different and how different things are similar.

Before we get to suggestions for tools and resources for panning, there are two important principles I want to discus: making learning meaningful and the importance of tracing errors.

Meaningful learning

First, the most important thing when learning to keep two things separate is to make the difference between them meaningful. This can’t be emphasized enough. If the difference between two common character components such as 良 and 艮 is just a single dot, it will be more or less impossible to remember this without further action. A dot is not meaningful in itself.

However, once you tie that to pronunciation and realize that characters that contain 良 are pronounced “-iang” (usually with “l-” or “n-“), while characters that contain 艮 are not (they are pronounced -in or -en with various initials), it’s much easier. The dot means something! I’ve written more about this in two articles about phonetic components:

You then use mnemonics to remember the difference. That means that you should have one specific mnemonic for 良 and another for 艮 that you can use to remember if there should be a dot or not.

Trace your errors to the source

The second thing you should do is to trace your errors. The more advanced your Chinese is, the more important this principle becomes. For example, if you write a character incorrectly, does the character you wrote mean something? What about the character component?

Continuing with the above of 良 and 艮, if you are to write 鄉 and can’t remember if there’s supposed to be a dot over 艮 or not, and don’t go to the bottom of the issue, you might study for years and still confuse the two character components.

However, by tracing your error to the source, you can solve the problems.In this case, it means learning about the phonetic components at work. And, most importantly, you not only solve this particular problem, you solve the same problem for dozens of other characters that also use 良 and 艮.

Naturally, not all errors lead to goldmines that help you solve all your problems. In some cases, the answer is lost in time or very hard to find.

Tools and resources for panning

While tools and resources were the main focus of previous articles, this article is more about being aware of the problem and the principles I’ve mentioned above. However, there are some resources that might come in handy:

Conclusion

That means the end of this little series of articles discussing how to better integrate your knowledge through zooming and panning. I hope you will find it useful!



Tips and tricks for how to learn Chinese directly in your inbox

I've been learning and teaching Chinese for more than a decade. My goal is to help you find a way of learning that works for you. Sign up to my newsletter for a 7-day crash course in how to learn, as well as weekly ideas for how to improve your learning!




4 comments

  1. Dian says:

    Hi Ollie, Thanks for several years of help with my Chinese learning. In this article I tried the link to Horizontal Hanzi but it took me to a page bloccked by porn. I wanted to let you know that perhaps the link needs some correction. Also, I have a suggestion. It would be helpful for me if you dated your articles since sometimes suggestions get out of date as to content on other sites. Of course your learning hacks don’t become outdated! In fact, my learning journey progresses I have reread many articles because I get different info based on my new learning needs. Just tonight I discovered your Patreon page. I never noticed it before and look forward to joining you. Dian🙂

    1. Olle Linge says:

      Hi! Thank you so much for pointing out the problem with the Horizontal Hanzi link, I have now deleted it entirely! As for dates, all my articles are have a publication date, it’s right there at the bottom of the post. 🙂 Regarding Patreon, I’m not doing much there actively these days and have decided to provide most things for free (such as the podcast), but support is of course welcome! I might also do more with Patreon later if/when I have more time to spend on Hacking Chinese.

  2. huey says:

    Could you give an example of something that is “how different things are similar?”

    1. Olle Linge says:

      I think this whole series needs an upgrade! Apart from the old links and outdated resources, there aren’t enough examples and I don’t really explain some things very well. This was written almost eight years ago, but here’s what I think I meant (or it is what I mean now, at least): Some things appear different, but are actually the same. 心 and 忄 are the same, but look different. What you asked about is the opposite, so things that look similar, but are actually different. On the component level, there are many examples: 灬 is sometimes fire, sometimes not. In simplified Chinese, 又 is a wildcard stand-in for almost anything (see here).

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.