- Blog (recent articles)
- Ask a question
- HC elsewhere
- Attitude and mentality
- Key study hacks
- Organising and planning
- Learning outside class
- Learning in class
- Immersion and integration
- Distinctively Chinese
- Recommended resources
- Science and research
- Essential articles
- Twitter archive
During the time I’ve studied Chinese, I’ve come a cross enough examples of people overstating the importance of being a native speaker to lead me to think that it’s a general trend and not an isolated phenomenon. For instance, people are embarrassed when I know words in Chinese they don’t (“I’m a native speaker, why don’t I know this word?”) or they can’t understand why I have a category in Anki for Swedish words (“You’re Swedish, why do you need to learn Swedish words?”).
This attitude is so bizarre it left me baffled the first few times. At first, I thought that people who said this were just more ignorant than the rest of the population, but I’ve come across this so often that it can no longer be dismissed as coincidence: people really seem to think that native speakers know everything about their own language, although it’s obvious that they don’t. This also means that most native speakers over-estimate their own language ability.
This article might sound a bit harsh, and therefore I want to state clearly that my goal is not to bash native speakers or to elevate my own ability in any way. I’m a native speaker of Swedish and having taught Swedish to foreigners, I know there are lots of things I don’t know or can’t explain (and I’m a teacher!). There will always be, but that’s part of the fun. I’ve also learnt English, Chinese and French which means I can approach the subject from those angles as well. I’m also grateful to a lot of native speakers, so this article should in no way be regarded as diminishing their contribution.
My goal here is to point out that people generally think that being a native speaker is the same as being really good in all areas of that language, and that I think this notion is mostly false. I also want to point out that someone who masters a language as a second language will have different skills from someone learning it as their native language. This is not good or bad; it simply is that way.
There are native speakers and then there are native speakers
The first mistake people make is to lump native speakers together in one single group. There is a huge difference between a native speaker who reads a hundred books a year and has a PhD, and a native speaker who dropped out of school at the age of fifteen and spends all his free time playing baseball. Native speakers learn their own language to whatever extent is required of them, which means that the baseball player above will have a very weak grasp of formal and written language.
Of course, the opposite is also true, that the PhD will know less about baseball. Still, pursuing a career which is heavily based on language (anything even remotely academic) is bound to increase your vocabulary enormously, so thinking that native speakers are homogeneous group is just stupid. Research suggests that the number of words that are used in everyday conversation is indeed very low; advanced vocabulary is only needed when discussing something specific or reading something on a decent level of complexity or abstraction.
Native speakers, second language learners and teachers
Different people are good at different things. When you read the items below, keep in mind what you can learn from native speakers and what you can learn from other second language learners. For instance, if you want someone to point out when you make mistakes with your pronunciation or practise conversation with you, nothing beats a native speaker. However, if you want to know exactly how to change your pronunciation or enhance your grammar, you need more specialised help, preferably from a teacher.
- Native speakers have a very good grasp of all practical aspects of their own language, but most of them have a fairly weak grasp of theoretical aspects (such as grammar, phonetics and so on). Just because a Chinese person can speak Mandarin for ten hours straight with perfect communication results doesn’t mean that the language he uses is 100% correct. Reading students essays in your native language is a good way of proving to yourself that not everybody masters their own language, not even students at university.
- Native speakers pronunciation is usually far from any kind of standardised pronunciation (a very low percentage of China’s population speaks perfect Mandarin), which of course isn’t wrong per se, but might be something to keep in mind as a second language learner. If you plan on teaching the language in the future, this might be very important. Having a very regional accent is fine if you live in that region, but I don’t think it will earn you any extra points if you look for a teaching job (or any employment) anywhere else. Heavy accent is usually as sign of a low education level and few people want that. Teachers usually have very good pronunciation and is usually the best way to learn proper pronunciation.
- Teachers and second language learners can usually explain grammar better. There are many aspects of Chinese that you have to study to learn (try asking random Chinese person how to use 了 and see what happens). Advanced second language learners and teachers usually possess this ability and is able to explain it to you so you can understand what you need to know. This can be accessed both in person as well as through textbooks, which are written by teachers or advanced foreign learners.
Why is this important?
This insight is important when you learn a second language from native speakers. Don’t think that their knowledge of their own language is infallible just because they are native speakers! For example, I’ve come across many people in Taiwan (some even teachers), who cannot explain the third tone in Mandarin properly. They think that they are accurately describing how they pronounce a given sound, but in reality they are doing something else and their explanations go against a vast body of research.
This is not to say that second language learners in general know more than native speakers, but rather that just because someone is a native speaker it doesn’t mean he’s superior to a second language learner in all situations. Thus, finding second language learners at a more advanced level than yourself is a good idea. Trusting native speakers always to give you the right answer is also bound to create problems.
Also, native speakers can’t always agree on what is correct in Chinese. What happens quite often is that I get corrected by one native speaker, only to have another one correct me in the other direction. This isn’t necessarily because one is right and the other one wrong, it’s just that Chinese is like that sometimes, it depends on region, background and so on.
Some suggestions and final comments
If you teach your own language, be open and admit that there are lots of things you don’t know. That’s okay and nothing to be ashamed of. Rather, it’s an opportunity to learn and develop further. You will be right most of the time, but thinking that you will be right every time is a sign of ignorance and hubris.
If you’re learning Chinese (or any other language), be aware of the fact that native speakers vary greatly in their own language ability and also in their ability to explain grammar, pronunciation or anything else you might be interested in learning. If you’re lucky, you will be able to find people who really know what they’re doing.
Please consider supporting Hacking Chinese so that I can keep providing free content.
Table of ContentsWelcome!
Attitude and mentality
Organising and planning
Key study hacks
Learning in class
Learning outside class
Immersion and integration
Science and research
A chronological list of all posts
An alphabetical list of all tags
About Hacking Chinese
- Sean on Don’t use mnemonics for everything
- Sean on Adding tone marks (w/o Pinyin) above characters to practise tones
- David Lloyd-Jones on Want to master Chinese in no time? Start dreaming!*
- Olle Linge on Using Audacity to learn Chinese (speaking and listening)
- Olle Linge on Using Audacity to learn Chinese (speaking and listening)
- Using Audacity to learn Chinese (speaking and listening)
- Adding tone marks (w/o Pinyin) above characters to practise tones
- Hacking Chinese meet-up in Taipei 2013-05-12
- You might be too lazy to learn Chinese, but you’re not too old
- Immersion at home or: Why you don’t have to go abroad to learn Chinese
Article tagsAnki Attitude Being corrected Benchmarking Challenge Character components Characters Culture Diversified learning Efficiency Friends Goals Grammar Handwriting HSK Immersion Language exchange Leeches Listening strategies Manga memory Micro goals Mistakes Mnemonics Motivation Music Native speakers passive listening Planning Pronunciation Radicals Recording Reviews Rote learning Sensible character learning Short-term goals Skritter Spaced repetition software SRS Teachers Tones Toolkit Vocabulary Words Zhongwen.com