- Blog (recent articles)
- Ask a question
- HC elsewhere
- Attitude and mentality
- Key study hacks
- Organising and planning
- Learning outside class
- Learning in class
- Immersion and integration
- Distinctively Chinese
- Recommended resources
- Science and research
- Essential articles
- Twitter archive
As soon as new students learn that there are two writing systems, they usually ask the same kind of questions. They want to know which one they should learn and how difficult it is to use one if you’ve learnt the other. In this post, I’ll share some of the answers I usually give for these kinds of questions.
The short, to-the-point summary is that which character set you choose matters much less than you probably think. I will also discuss how to learn traditional if you’ve learnt simplified first and vice versa. If you’re serious about learning Chinese, I really think you should learn both, but the later you do it, the easier it will become, so don’t stress it.
What’s the difference anyway?
In case you’ve just started learning Chinese, traditional Chinese refers to the characters used before the simplification reforms during the second half of the 20th century in Mainland China. This means that traditional characters are still being used in Taiwan, Hong Kong and in many overseas Chinese communities. Simplified characters are then, as the name implies, simplifications of the traditional characters. The simplification process is a complicated one and there are many different types of simplifications (most characters are older or existing variant forms of the traditional character or systematic changes certain parts, whereas a few are really entirely new characters). We’ll look closer at this later.
Which character set should I learn as a beginner?
This question is either very easy or impossible to answer. For most people, simplified Chinese is the obvious choice, because most Chinese speaking people in the world use it. People living in Taiwan or Hong Kong naturally learn traditional Chinese to a larger extent. So, I’d say that the question is answered automatically by where you live or where you plan to live. I suppose you really have to choose if you don’t live in a Chinese speaking environment and don’t plan to live in such an environment any time soon. Still, I’d say that the default character set for most people should be simplified Chinese, even though I can come up with a few reasons why learning traditional Chinese first might more beneficial in some situations. This, however, is not within the scope of this week’s article.
The difference between simplified and traditional are much smaller than most people think
To a beginner, the characters look very, very different. You might have seen a few examples online (such as the picture above) and now you feel terrified, thinking that if you learn to read simplified, you will never be able to communicate in writing with people in Taiwan or Hong Kong, or that your Chinese will be useless on the Mainland if you’ve learnt Chinese in Taiwan. Just look at the following examples, with traditional forms first and then their simplified counterparts:
- 聽 － 听
- 豐 － 丰
- 議 － 议
However, these examples most people use to illustrate the differences are extremes. These are among the biggest differences there are and are very, very far from being typical. Let’s have a look at the following characters and see if you think they are easier:
- 銳 － 锐
- 銘 － 铭
- 釘 － 钉
- 鎮 － 鎮
- 釣 － 钓
Doesn’t look so scary, right? As we can clearly see, the only thing that has changed in these characters is the radical: 釒-> 钅. It takes about five seconds to learn the above characters, provided you know either the simplified or the traditional version first. And these aren’t the only ones, most simplifications are really this easy.
A closer look at the simplification process
A huge majority of simplified characters are based on systematic simplification of radicals and/or character parts. The above examples using 釒/钅 are typical, so I didn’t include them just to make you feel good. This means that just by learning a few hundred patterns (such as 釒-> 钅) , you can understand most of what’s written using the character set you’re not familiar with. These patterns are usually (but not always) very easy and can be learnt simply by looking at them once. Understanding that 訁becomes 讠 or that 糹becomes 纟really isn’t that hard, even if it takes some time getting used to the new forms.
That being said, there are some characters that have been morphed beyond recognition or that make use of ancient variants that look very different indeed. This means that there are around five hundred “tricky cases” that you need to learn. However, learning 500 characters isn’t very hard on an advanced level and can be done in a matter of weeks. I learnt traditional before learning simplified and it took me less than a month to be able to read books in simplified Chinese. Sure, reading quickly and comfortably takes more time than that, but I can understand simplified Chinese without too much trouble. Writing is harder, but wouldn’t be too hard with some practise.
A suggested plan of action
So, you know one set and want to learn the other? Great! First you should consider when to do this. I would say that you should wait as long as is practically possible. If you do it early, confusion will ensue. If you know several thousand characters already, however, learning the other set will be easy.
Here’s a suggested plan of action:
- Go through and learn the systematic changes
- Note and learn any exceptions (use my deck in Anki (search for “tricky simplifications”), based on Renzhe’s original, or download a text version here)
- Use some kind of SRS to learn those tricky cases
- Read a book or two
It really is that simple. Possibly, you could do without step three and skip directly to reading, but I at feast feel a bit safer after making sure that I have learnt the tricky cases. I still might not be able to write them by hand, but I do recognise them which is enough for most situations. There are some really tricky cases and some merges of characters that are difficult to handle, but these make up a very small part of what you have to learn, so I really don’t think they are a big problem.
I’d like to end this article by saying this: Most people who have not learnt both character sets have felt daunted by the challenge, but every single learner I’ve talked to who have actually learnt the other set as well have said that they thought it was easy.
I suppose that what I want to say is: don’t worry: it isn’t as bad as it looks.
List of all radicals (see the “simplified character” column)
Ambiguities in Chinese character simplification
List of character parts that can also be used alone
List of simplifications that can’t be used in compositions
Wikipedia’s article (contains links to all other simplifications)
Please consider supporting Hacking Chinese so that I can keep providing free content.
Table of ContentsWelcome!
Attitude and mentality
Organising and planning
Key study hacks
Learning in class
Learning outside class
Immersion and integration
Science and research
A chronological list of all posts
An alphabetical list of all tags
About Hacking Chinese
- Learning how to learn Chinese through self-experimentation | Hacking Chinese - 揭密中文 on Anki, the best of spaced repetition software
- Using Audacity to Practice Chinese | The World of Chinese on Recording yourself to improve speaking ability
- Using Audacity to Practice Chinese | The World of Chinese on Benchmarking progress to stay motivated
- Using Audacity to Practice Chinese | The World of Chinese on Using Audacity to learn Chinese (speaking and listening)
- Ed Bockelman on 31 Twitter feeds to help you learn Chinese
Article tagsAnki Attitude Being corrected Benchmarking Challenge Character components Characters Culture Diversified learning Efficiency Friends Goals Grammar Handwriting HSK Immersion Language exchange Leeches Listening strategies Manga memory Micro goals Mistakes Mnemonics Motivation Music Native speakers passive listening Planning Pronunciation Radicals Recording Reviews Rote learning Sensible character learning Short-term goals Skritter Spaced repetition software SRS Teachers Tones Toolkit Vocabulary Words Zhongwen.com